hiring the wrong producer

Stop Hiring the Wrong Producer Every January

By
Randy Schwantz
Nov 17, 2026

Hiring Marathoners With a 40-Yard Dash

December is cut season.

This is the time of year when owners finally have the conversation they’ve put off all year with the producer who didn’t make it. In January, they’ll fill the chair.

Ask one of those owners why the producer failed and you’ll get an answer fast. Ask what will be different about the next hire and you’ll often get a long pause.

That pause is how agencies end up hiring the wrong producer twice.

One Word in Hindsight

In GRIT, my book on finding, hiring and developing real producers, I described a session led by Dr. Craft. He dimmed the lights and asked a room of sales leaders to close their eyes and think of “the last producer they had to ‘fire’.” Then he asked them to reduce their frustration to the single trait they believed caused the failure.

The whiteboards filled up with the same list: “being lazy, no sense of urgency, being noncompetitive, no ‘fire in the belly’, being unmotivated, and unable to leave their comfort zone.”

Read that list again. Almost every word points at one thing. Drive.

Notice what the list leaves out. Coverage knowledge. Carrier relationships. Product training. You can teach those in a conference room. 

Those sales leaders knew exactly what failure looked like. In hindsight it fit on a whiteboard in one word.

Try it yourself before you read another line. Your last cut. One word.

A 40-Yard Dash for a Marathon

Now look at how most agencies pick the next producer. A résumé. Two or three interviews. A lunch. Maybe a personality profile.

That’s a 40-yard dash. It measures what a candidate can do for one hour with full energy and his best answers rehearsed. Confident. Likable. Quick on his feet. A few people are great at it.

The job is a marathon. A producer typically takes three to five years to become validated. The trait that decides the race shows up around month twelve. The friends-and-family accounts are written. Three prospects in a row just told him no. Nobody is watching his calendar at 2:00 on a Thursday.

Drive is a distance trait. It shows up only over distance.

So the agency cuts the runner who quit at mile eight. Then in January it lines up the next candidates and times another 40-yard dash.

In GRIT I put it bluntly: “the traditional ‘personality’ profile along with a ‘candy ass’ interview is not enough to determine if a producer candidate has the grit to make it.”

Why a Great Interview Feels Like Proof

If owners already know the interview misses drive, why do they keep trusting it? Psychology has an answer, and it’s humbling.

As a young psychologist in the Israeli Army, Daniel Kahneman helped rate officer candidates by watching them work through a group obstacle exercise. When the picture of a soldier came together, he wrote, “we were completely confident in our evaluations.” Months later the training school’s results came back. Their “ability to predict performance at the school was negligible.”

Then came the part every agency owner needs to hear. They rated the next group of candidates the same way, with the same certainty. “The dismal truth about the quality of our predictions had no effect whatsoever on how we evaluated new candidates.” Kahneman called it the illusion of validity.

Confidence comes from how neatly the story hangs together. A great interview hands you a neat story. Firm handshake. Good answers. Says he’s competitive. Played ball in college. The story feels like evidence, and your gut signs off.

That’s the December and January loop. December’s cut is your dismal truth. January’s great interview is the next candidate. And the confidence feels exactly as strong as it did a year ago, when you hired the person you just let go. That’s the engine behind hiring the wrong producer year after year.

Here’s what it costs. Another year of salary and benefits. Another year of your own time spent trying to motivate someone. Another empty spot on next year’s new business report. Run that loop a few times and you’re living inside the producer failure rate everyone in this industry complains about.

Measure the Distance Trait Before You Hire

The fix is to stop letting the sprint answer a distance question. You have to determine a producer’s drive and motivation before you hire them.

Here’s how to stop hiring the wrong producer this January.

Turn your one word into a requirement. Write down the trait from your last cut. Put it at the top of the job requirements before you read a single résumé. If the last producer lacked urgency, urgency is now the first thing you test.

Measure it before the interview. Get data on drive while your judgment is still clean, before a great lunch tilts you. A sales hiring assessment built for producers, like our GRIT Personality Inventory (GPI), scores Intensity/Drive and weights it as its top predictor. It also scores Optimism, which is resilience after rejection.

Watch them over distance. The interview process in GRIT is stretched out on purpose. You can see this candidate over time instead of just one interview. Give homework. See who does it, and how well. Likability is the easiest thing to see in a sprint, and we’ve written about why hiring producers because they’re likable backfires.

Grade your own confidence. Pull the interview notes on your last three hires. Next to each one, write how sure you were and how it turned out. If the two columns don’t match, you’ve found your own illusion of validity. Now you know how much weight to give your gut.

Refuse the year-end rush. An empty chair and a January start date push owners to skip steps. GRIT has a line for that too: If you take shortcuts because you’re in a hurry, you just made a mistake.

One more thing. If you’re still deciding about a producer who’s behind, read why owners keep a struggling producer too long before you decide.

Make December’s Cut Count

Nobody enjoys the cut. You liked him. You hired him. You told your partners he’d make it. And he’s a person with a family who gave you a year he won’t get back.

The worst version of this story is doing it again next December with someone new. Same conversation. Same pit in your stomach. A different name on the door. It’s how hiring the wrong producer becomes a habit, and how a growth plan becomes a turnover plan.

Your last cut already told you what to look for. Your January hire deserves a process that actually looks for it.

Before you sign the next offer letter, run your top candidate through the GPI. It takes 15 to 30 minutes for the candidate. Your first assessment is free, with no credit card required, and you get the full report, so you can see exactly which traits it surfaces before you decide whether to use it again. Treat it as one input alongside your interviews and references. It’s built for agency leaders who want to find out before the hire whether a candidate has the drive to go the distance.

P.S. If you’re an owner ready to talk now, book an Agency Diagnostic Call.

SHARE THIS
READ MORE
Free Live Training
Escape the Top Producer Trap

Double Your Agency Revenue

Join Randy Schwantz for a live session on the 3 systemic gaps keeping your agency stuck in single-digit growth - and how to fix them.

72%
Producer
Success Rate
39%
Revenue Growth
in Year 1
70%+
Close
Rates
Register Now - It's Free

This Wednesday at 12:00 PM ET · Limited seats